Family Thanksgiving traditions worth keeping
Six years ago, I wrote a Thanksgiving post on this blog that was exactly two sentences long. It called 2020 a "difficult, challenging but eye-opening" year and said that if you stepped back, you'd find plenty to be thankful for.
I stand by every word. But two sentences don't help much when you've got a house full of relatives and a turkey that's still frozen on Wednesday night.
My boys are grown now, or close to it, so I've had a lot of Novembers to see which family Thanksgiving traditions stuck and which ones quietly died. Here are the ones worth keeping, plus a few new ones I'd try if my kids were little again.
Family Thanksgiving traditions at a glance
Here's the short list. The how-to for each one is below.
Tradition | When | What it takes |
Give everyone a job | Day before and morning of | A list of kid-sized tasks |
Watch the parade in pajamas | Thanksgiving morning | A TV and a couch |
Get everyone outside | Before or after the meal | Shoes and a football (snow, even better) |
Go around the table | Before the first bite | Five minutes |
Keep a thankful tablecloth | Dinner, every year | A plain cloth and fabric markers |
Set an extra chair | Dinner | One more place setting |
Ask the oldest guest for a story | After dinner | Your phone's voice recorder |
Take the same photo every year | After dinner | Same spot, same order |
Make Friday the leftover day | The day after | A fridge within two hours |
Give back together | Any day that week | One phone call, made early |
Say a prayer | Before the eating begins | Getting everyone together |
What makes a Thanksgiving tradition worth keeping?
A tradition is worth keeping if your kids would notice it was gone. That's my whole test.
Researchers have looked at whether family rituals matter at all. A 2002 review in the Journal of Family Psychology pulled together 50 years of research on family routines and rituals and found them linked to kids' adjustment, parenting competence, and even marital satisfaction.
Linked isn't the same as caused, and the authors flagged the limits of those studies themselves. Still, it matches what I've seen at my own table.
The family Thanksgiving traditions that lasted in our house had two things in common. They were easy enough to pull off in a tired year, and everybody had a part in them.
My youngest and I started a tradition of making Gordon Ramsay’s Beef Wellington. It worked the first year because his friends came over and everyone pitched in. But when you’re doing it alone, it may be time to simplify and focus elsewhere. The dish takes a lot of time, but even for one year, it was worth it.
10 Thanksgiving traditions worth keeping
1. Give everyone a job, kids included
Give every person at the table a real job, from the four-year-old to Grandpa. A job turns a kid from someone underfoot into someone who helped make dinner.
Little ones can wash potatoes, tear bread for the stuffing, or make place cards. Older kids can peel, mash, set the table, or run the timer.
While you're at it, pass down one family recipe. My family is originally from Poland, so I have a special place in my heart for kielbasa. We have a favorite meat market in Toledo, OH where I was born, so we splurge on shipping and have it for the holidays with fresh horseradish.
2. Watch the parade in pajamas
Turn on the parade, stay in your pajamas, and give the cooks a quiet kitchen for a few hours. It's the easiest tradition on this list.
The 2026 Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade is the 100th one, with a record 100 inflatables in the lineup. It starts at 8:30 a.m. in every time zone on NBC and Peacock. We each have our favorites along with amazement on the ones that are still a part of the parade.
3. Get everyone outside at least once
Get the whole crew outside at least once, before the meal or after it. A morning walk or a local turkey trot works up an appetite, and a backyard football game after dinner burns off the pie.
If you're in Texas like me, the Cowboys game is probably on somewhere in the house. They've played on Thanksgiving Day almost every year since 1966. Play first, watch second.
4. Go around the table
Before anyone eats, go around the table and have each person name one thing they're thankful for. It takes five minutes, and nobody gets skipped, including the toddler and the teenager who'd rather be anywhere else.
If your family says grace, start there. I wrote about getting kids comfortable praying out loud if yours are new to it.
Keep it short with teenagers, because one honest sentence beats a forced speech.
5. Keep a thankful tablecloth
Keep one plain fabric tablecloth just for Thanksgiving, and have everyone write on it with fabric markers. Each person adds one thing they're thankful for, their name, and the year.
Little kids can trace their hands instead. In a few years, you'll have a tablecloth that shows exactly how big those hands got.
6. Set an extra chair
Set one more place than you need and fill it with someone who'd otherwise eat alone. Think of a widowed neighbor, a coworker who can't fly home, or a college kid stuck on campus.
If they'd rather stay home, have the kids carry a plate over. They'll learn more from that walk across the street than from anything you say at the table.
7. Ask the oldest person at the table for one story
After dinner, ask the oldest person at the table one good question and hit record. Try "What was Thanksgiving like when you were a kid?" and then stop talking.
My dad has been gone for almost two decades. But when my dad was here, we always got together on Thanksgiving or Christmas, alternating with my wife’s family. We just made it happen and my three sisters and their families were always there.
If you want the simple setup, here's how I record the stories only the grown-ups know.
8. Take the same photo every year
Line everyone up in the same spot, in the same order, every Thanksgiving. It takes two minutes, and after ten years you've got a flip-book of your family growing up.
Your phone is fine for this. If you want sharper group shots in a dim dining room, here are the cameras I'd recommend to a busy dad.
9. Make Friday the leftover day
The day after Thanksgiving is for leftovers, and nobody cooks from scratch. Turkey sandwiches for lunch, and pie for breakfast if you're brave.
There's one rule, and it isn't mine. The USDA says to get leftovers into the fridge within two hours and eat them within three to four days or freeze them.
Friday's turkey sandwich is fine. By Monday, freeze what's left or say goodbye. If it’s still left on Monday, we normally say goodbye!
10. Give back together
Pick one way to help someone else that week and do it as a family. Drop off a meal, fill a box for the food pantry, or sign up for a volunteer shift.
Call early, because holiday volunteer slots at food banks fill up fast. Pantries need help the rest of the year, too.
Being charitable is a lot easier to teach when your kids watch you do it.
How to start new Thanksgiving traditions
Start one new tradition a year, keep it small, and give it three Thanksgivings before you decide whether it's a keeper. The first year almost always feels forced.
Let the kids vote on it, too. The traditions my boys asked for by name were never the ones I planned hardest.
If you're short on ideas, these new Thanksgiving traditions are easy to try:
A pie bake-off, with the kids as judges
A "wildcard" dish, where one person adds something new to the menu
Five candy corns at every plate, one for each thing you're thankful for
A Friendsgiving on Saturday for friends who couldn't make Thursday
Thanksgiving with kids: what I'd tell a younger dad
Thanksgiving with kids goes better when you plan their day as carefully as the menu.
Feed them before the feast. Dinner always runs late, and hungry kids don't wait politely.
Put one food they love on the table. A bowl of mac and cheese next to the green bean casserole never hurt anybody.
Build in a break between dinner and pie. Ten minutes outside resets everybody, adults included.
Lower the bar. Somebody will spill the gravy, and the group photo will have one kid looking the wrong way. It still counts.
Common questions about Thanksgiving traditions
What are some classic family Thanksgiving traditions?
The classics are the parade in the morning, football in the afternoon, saying what you're thankful for at the table, and breaking the wishbone. The best ones are usually small things only your family does.
What are good Thanksgiving traditions for families with teenagers?
Give teenagers real responsibility and a little room. Put them in charge of a dish, let them bring a friend, or three, and keep the thankful round short.
We always give our kids the option to invite a friend. That has worked well for us over the years and keeps them closer to home. On the flip side, if they want to join their friends at their house, that works too. We make sure we get the fun things in before they leave.
How do you keep a tradition going when family is spread out?
Pick something you can do from anywhere at the same time. A video call during pie, the same recipe cooked in three kitchens, or a group text of everyone's thankful list all count.
One last thing
Your family Thanksgiving traditions don't have to look like anyone else's. Pick one from this list, do it again next year, and let your kids tell you if it's a keeper.
And if the turkey comes out dry, pass the gravy. Nobody remembers the turkey.
What makes a tradition stick is the same thing that helps kids feel close to a busy dad: you show up for the small stuff, year after year.
Helping one dad a day...mark
Comments